16.7 C
Cape Town
Friday, November 20, 2026

Carney Secures Trade Deal with China Amid Controversy and Criticism

Prime Minister Mark Carney has successfully negotiated...

From Humble Beginnings to Record-Breaking Success: The GTA Journey

During the development of the initial Grand...

Gas Prices Drop Across Canada, National Average Now $1.514/Litre

No, you’re not imagining things — gas...

Kinew Opposes Criminalizing Residential School Denialism, Advocates Education

NationalKinew Opposes Criminalizing Residential School Denialism, Advocates Education

Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew has expressed his strong opposition to the idea of criminalizing residential school denialism, deeming it reprehensible but not a legal offense. He made this statement in response to efforts by federal Manitoba NDP member Leah Gazan to include this issue in the Criminal Code.

“I hold MP Gazan in high regard, but I do not believe we can make this a criminal act. Our focus should instead be on ongoing education and fighting misinformation,” Kinew conveyed during a conversation with CBC Manitoba Information Radio host Marcy Markusa on Friday.

Gazan initially presented Bill C-254, her private member’s bill aimed at modifying the Criminal Code to address the promotion of hatred against Indigenous peoples, in October 2024. However, the bill was shelved when the spring 2025 election was announced.

“If the government is genuinely committed to reconciliation, they must safeguard survivors and their families from hatred,” Gazan stated upon first introducing the legislation.

“The residential school system constituted a genocide intended to eradicate Indigenous cultures, languages, families, and heritage. To trivialize, deny, or justify this is inhumane and harmful.”

She reintroduced the bill in October 2025. The proposed legislation aims to prohibit anyone from condoning, denying, justifying, or minimizing the Indian residential school system in Canada through any public statements, excluding private discussions.

All proposed bills undergo three readings, which include committee evaluations and concluding debates, prior to receiving royal assent and becoming law.

The introduction marked the initial reading. The bill has not yet proceeded to a second reading.

For a span exceeding 150 years, from the 1830s until 1997, First Nations, Inuit, and Métis children were removed from their homes and communities to attend residential schools, often located far away. Most of these institutions were funded by the government and operated by Christian religious organizations.

These schools aimed to assimilate Indigenous children into Euro-Canadian culture. Approximately 150,000 children across Canada attended these schools, and the National Centre for Truth and Reconciliation has recorded over 4,000 deaths among attendees.

On September 30, the National Day for Truth and Reconciliation, Kinew announced that the province collaborated with the City of Brandon to acquire a well-known campground site that was previously part of the Brandon Residential School, operational from 1895 until 1972.

The campground site included a former cemetery utilized from 1895 to 1912, as stated in a news release issued by the province on the day of the acquisition announcement.

A sign with text that includes "Brandon Residential School Burial Ground -- Please Walk Gently."

This sign is located at the Brandon Residential School cemetery site. Historical records indicate the cemetery, where children from the school were laid to rest, was in use from 1895 to 1912. The area subsequently became a park and then a privately owned campground. (Jaison Empson/CBC)

According to the province, the land still contains the remains of children.

Kinew, who held a memorial at the site on September 30, remarked on Friday that such events are pivotal in raising awareness about residential schools.

“The documentation is extensive. It’s a significant part of history. Therefore, it is crucial that we preserve this history in our collective memory as a province,” he stated.

The Sioux Valley Dakota Nation, which owns the land where the school once stood, will oversee decisions regarding the former cemetery and is collaborating with university researchers to identify the more than 50 children believed to be buried there.

Rev. Stan McKay, whose maternal grandparents were compelled to attend the Brandon Residential School for a significant portion of their lives and never spoke of it, described the acquisition of the cemetery land as a “very important piece” in the reconciliation process.

“It was not a good place,” McKay remarked on the day of the province’s announcement.

A group of people sit inside a teepee.

Kinew takes part in a ceremony on the National Day for Truth and Reconciliation after the Manitoba government announced its partnership with the City of Brandon for the campground land purchase. (Jaison Empson/CBC)

His elder sisters also spent two years at the Brandon school, while he himself is a survivor of the Fisher River and Birtle residential schools.

The United Church of Canada was one of three religious organizations that managed the Brandon school throughout its lengthy history. Later, McKay made history as the first Indigenous leader of that church.

He mentioned that he nearly distanced himself from the church after realizing he had been colonized by it. However, elders, who also had “some difficulties with the church,” encouraged him to remain and work within the system to facilitate change, McKay noted.

McKay expressed a desire for enhanced education in Manitoba schools regarding the residential school experience, emphasizing the importance of localizing content to the 18 schools that operated within the province.

Kinew concurred on Friday that this would be beneficial and pointed out that significantly more is being accomplished in schools now compared to past decades.

“The difference in knowledge about residential schools between what we learned in K-12 and what today’s children learn is enormous,” he remarked.

Kinew emphasized the necessity for education to extend beyond school walls as well.

“While preparing for Brandon… I discussed with some of my close colleagues—very intelligent people—and when I referenced the volume of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission documenting child deaths, they were shocked. They had no idea about the number of fatalities,” he shared.

“Certainly, more work is required within the K-12 system, but there is also a lot to be done in workplaces, churches, sports, and all community gatherings where we need to keep this history alive.

“What we must avoid is allowing this to fade from our collective memory, leading to the risk of repeating past mistakes.”

Check out our other content

Check out other tags:

Most Popular Articles