Gains in Canada-China trade deal don’t go both ways, says Kovrig
Michael Kovrig, a former diplomat who spent over 1,000 days in captivity in China on spying allegations, emphasizes the need for careful management of the trade relationship with China, stating that the benefits of Prime Minister Mark Carney’s new trade agreement are skewed in favor of China.
Former President Trump has negotiated trade agreements with China and referred to Xi as a “great leader.” His administration is currently dealing with repercussions related to the scandal involving the ex-CEO of Nvidia and an alleged Chinese spy.
Trump’s commerce secretary, Howard Lutnick, has also been accused of attempting to relax U.S. chip export regulations to favor Asian AI data centers that engage with China.
Despite this controversial backdrop, Peter Navarro, a trade advisor to Trump and frequent critic of Canada, labeled Carney’s interactions with China as “extremely offensive.”
“China will consume Canada,” he declared.
Nevertheless, initial outcomes indicate that setting aside negative Chinese actions is yielding positive results for Canadian enterprises and their workforce.
Xi has committed to eliminating “anti-discriminatory tariffs,” which can reach as high as 25 percent on certain $400 million of Canadian pork and seafood products — a strategic move that immediately benefits those sectors by providing access to China’s immense food market.
Along with a pledge to import more lentils, fava beans, “wild aquatic products,” and pet food, among other agricultural goods, Xi is also extending the tariff suspension Carney achieved in January for Canadian canola meal, peas, lobster, and crab, which has proven economically advantageous.
Indeed, since Carney’s initial meeting with Xi, alongside what the government claims is 35 additional ministerial visits aimed at addressing bilateral tensions, Canadian exports to China have skyrocketed.
Data from Statistics Canada and the University of Alberta’s China Institute reveal that Canadian trade with China reached an unprecedented $12.7 billion last quarter.
The monetary value of Canadian goods exported to the Asian economic giant has surged by 60 percent over the last two years, a result of Carney’s efforts to mend relations with Beijing.
Kyle Larkin, president and CEO of the Canadian Meat Council, noted that pork producers have faced hardships due to the Chinese restrictions, and Carney’s agreement to lift many of these is “a significant step forward.”
“We are quite pleased,” he expressed to reporters in China.
Vina Nadjibulla, co-founder and CEO of the Centre for Strategic Statecraft, stated that U.S. trade policies necessitate Canada seeking other business opportunities, despite ongoing concerns about getting too close to China.
“China’s actions remain unchanged, but Canada’s strategic situation has evolved,” Nadjibulla remarked in an interview.
“We now exist in a reality where diversification is essential, and we must engage economically with China in specific sectors. Nonetheless, I hope we remain prudent and strategic and do not overlook past lessons.”
Increased Chinese steel and aluminum
In exchange for this expanded access, Carney is further opening the gateway to Chinese steel and aluminum imports by prolonging and broadening remission measures for products that are not sufficiently available domestically.
Blair Dickerson, president of the Canadian Steel Producers Association, indicated that these changes are not anticipated to significantly impact the domestic market.
“If there are items we cannot produce here, we are fine with it,” she commented in an interview, adding that the remissions are “not permanent” and could be reversed if local companies begin manufacturing those products.
There is also a vague promise to “enhance cooperation” in the area of “finance.”
Carney will continue to permit tens of thousands of Chinese electric vehicles to enter Canada each year at a lower tariff rate, although the quantity imported thus far is significantly below this year’s quota of 49,000.
A background document on the Carney-Xi agreement shared with reporters notes that, following previous approvals for BYD, another unnamed Chinese manufacturer has just obtained the necessary permissions from Transport Canada to import its foreign-made vehicles.
A government representative confirmed that Geely, an automotive conglomerate involved with brands like Zeekr, Polestar, and Lotus, has now received approval.
A significant portion of Canada’s automotive sector has vehemently opposed granting access to Chinese companies, fearing that an influx of cheaply manufactured, state-subsidized vehicles will undermine the remaining Canadian auto and parts manufacturing.
While the Carney administration initially anticipated substantial manufacturing investments from Chinese electric vehicle producers in Canada, nothing has yet come to fruition, and the background document released to reporters implies that none is forthcoming soon.
Flavio Volpe, president of the Automotive Parts Manufacturers’ Association (APMA), warned CBC News that Ottawa must resist any urge to allow Chinese companies to import “knock-down” car kits for assembly in Canada.
Volpe noted that Chinese firms have assured other nations like Brazil that these kits were merely a preliminary step until they could establish local manufacturing capabilities, only to later backtrack on those promises.
He warned that these kits contain no Canadian components, would jeopardize the domestic sector, and could frustrate the U.S., which supplies many parts to Canadian assembly facilities.
“Could this derail any chance of a trade agreement with the Americans? It certainly captures the Americans’ attention,” he commented regarding the potential increase of Chinese-made vehicles in Canada.
Despite industry concerns, Carney is demonstrating a willingness to collaborate with these Chinese companies amid strained relations with the U.S.
“We have the finest auto workforce in the world, and we want them fully utilized with ample opportunities in a cohesive North American market,” Carney told reporters accompanying him on his nine-day trade mission.
“That market has become less integrated due to U.S. trade actions.”