15.5 C
Cape Town
Sunday, November 22, 2026

Who Really Owns Canada? Examining Foreign Investment’s Impact

LISTEN | FRONT BURNER:Front Burner27:26Who owns Canada's...

Elks Celebrate First Grey Cup Win in Over a Decade with Free Event

The Edmonton Elks are organizing a public...

Canada’s Industry Minister Consults Lawyers After Stelco CEO’s Remarks

NationalCanada's Industry Minister Consults Lawyers After Stelco CEO's Remarks

The Canadian Minister of Industry has stated that she contacted the department’s legal team following remarks made by the CEO of Stelco’s American parent company, who claimed he purchased the Hamilton-based steel manufacturer to prevent it from undermining his production facilities in the U.S.

“The final comments from the president of Stelco definitely prompted us to reach out to our lawyers to explore potential consequences of such admissions,” Industry Minister Mélanie Joly explained on Wednesday.

These remarks were made after Cleveland-Cliffs CEO Lourenco Goncalves told CBC’s Power & Politics that the Hamilton firm was “undercutting our prices in the United States.”

He stated, “I acquired Stelco because I could no longer tolerate having Stelco saturate the market here in the United States, negatively affecting my own company,” during an interview with host David Cochrane.

Goncalves’s statements follow Cleveland-Cliffs’ response to Joly’s recent demands for the company to retract layoffs announced last month or face possible legal repercussions for breaching commitments under the Investment Canada Act.

The government asserts that the company had agreed in those commitments to maintain the number of unionized Stelco employees at 2024 levels until 2029 when the acquisition occurred.

In a letter sent to the company last week, Joly warned that failure to comply with its agreement with the federal government would lead to legal action. This could involve requesting financial penalties or an order mandating Cleveland-Cliffs to divest from Stelco.

WATCH | Stelco in ‘full compliance,’ asserts CEO:

Stelco in ‘full compliance’ with commitments to Ottawa, says CEO

October 27|

Duration

14:18

As the federal government faces off against Stelco regarding its layoffs in Hamilton, Power & Politics engages with the American owner of the steel plant about the potential for this conflict to escalate into a legal battle.

Goncalves maintains that his company is in “full compliance” with the commitments made under the Investment Canada Act when acquiring the steel manufacturer in 2024.

In a correspondence with The Canadian Press, Goncalves expressed his hope to reinstate laid-off Stelco employees before Christmas, contingent on a successful strategy to boost Canadian sales.

The CEO remarked on Power & Politics that he “takes issue” with the idea of needing to divest from Stelco, asserting that, for the time being, “the company is not for sale,” though that could change.

“I will sell the company after we run it for a while — and now that I’m aware that I’m persona non grata in Canada, that will be the course of action,” he stated.

He further added: “Give me another year. I’ll generate profits, sell the company.… [The] Minister of Industry is not a company realtor, and if she is, then she should sell some other business. This company has an owner, it’s Cleveland-Cliffs.”

‘It may not appear favorable at first glance’

Sandy Walker, an attorney specializing in competition law and the Investment Canada Act, notes that the Federal Court has the authority to compel Cleveland-Cliffs to divest from Stelco and can impose fines of up to $10,000 daily.

WATCH | CEO’s comments prompt Ottawa to seek legal counsel:

Stelco owner’s live TV admission prompts industry minister to call lawyers

October 28|

Duration

2:49

Industry Minister Mélanie Joly indicated that she reached out to the government’s lawyers after the CEO of Stelco’s American parent company disclosed to CBC News that he only acquired the Hamilton steelmaker to prevent it from undermining his production facilities in the U.S.

Furthermore, Joly pointed out that Goncalves’s statements on Power & Politics raise doubts about whether the company entered into the Investment Canada Act commitments with genuine intentions “if he was ultimately planning to shut down the company.”

Walker remarked that while “it may not appear favorable at first glance,” the situation is not necessarily straightforward for the government.

Walker explained that Canada must still establish that Cleveland-Cliffs was not influenced by factors outside its control when it initiated the layoffs.

“I don’t believe this case is clear-cut, nor is this admission from last night a definitive trap,” she commented.

“However, it does reflect the mindset of the signatory to these commitments, assuming [Goncalves] was the one who signed them, and it may indicate the extent of his efforts to fulfill those commitments.”

Walker highlighted that a Canadian court has never mandated a company to comply with the Investment Canada Act.

In 2009, the Canadian government initiated legal action against U.S. Steel after the then-owner of Stelco shut down numerous Canadian operations due to a downturn in global steel demand triggered by the 2008 financial crisis.

Ultimately, Ottawa withdrew the lawsuit in late 2011 when U.S. Steel reached an out-of-court settlement.

WATCH | Conservative MP calls on government to take legal action:

Conservative MP urges government to sue Stelco owner

October 28|

Duration

1:15

Conservative MP Ned Kuruc for Hamilton East—Stoney Creek expressed that ‘if the government has an iron-clad contract’ with Stelco’s American owner, Ottawa should take them to court over alleged violations of the company’s agreements. ‘Contracts are put in place to protect our interests and the workers,’ Kuruc remarked. ‘If we don’t enforce them, then what do we have?’

Conservative MP Ned Kuruc, who serves Hamilton-East Stoney Creek, has called on the government to pursue legal action.

“If the government possesses a solid contract… proceed with the lawsuit,” Kuruc urged. “We need decisive action. Take it to court and demonstrate that we are serious — because this ultimately reflects a lack of strength from our government.”

Check out our other content

Check out other tags:

Most Popular Articles