Netflix’s latest popular series, ‘Monster: The Ed Gein Story,’ sheds light on the infamous American killer, Ed Gein, also known as The Butcher of Plainfield. While Gein has been the inspiration behind various fictional monsters, this show marks the first time his real-life story is depicted in a true crime format.
In the series, actor Charlie Hunnam takes on the role of Gein, portraying significant events from the killer’s life, including his complex relationship with neighbor Adeline Watkins (played by Suzanna Son). The storyline delves into their engagement, Adeline’s relocation to New York, and her eventual separation from Gein.
A controversial aspect of the series is Adeline’s knowledge of Gein’s criminal acts, which allegedly fueled his macabre interests. The show depicts Adeline discussing Gein’s murderous tendencies publicly after his capture. Notably, a scene shows Gein proposing to her with a ring taken from a grave he desecrated.
The portrayal of Adeline and Gein’s relationship has sparked debate among viewers, with many questioning its authenticity. Adeline has since refuted claims of a two-decade romance with Gein, stating that they only met in 1954, well after Gein had engaged in disturbing behavior.
Amidst conflicting accounts, showrunner Ian Brennan defended Adeline’s inclusion in the series, citing her initial claims of being romantically involved with Gein. However, Adeline’s later denial and contradictory statements have added layers of mystery to their alleged connection.
In a 1957 interview with the Minneapolis Tribune, Watkins initially professed love for Gein, asserting a long-term relationship. Her mother also praised Gein as a courteous individual who ensured her daughter’s safety during their outings.
Watkins recalled their dates involving movies and visits to local establishments, highlighting Gein’s preference for milkshakes over alcohol. She mentioned engaging in discussions on crime, excluding any reference to Gein’s own atrocities.
Despite Watkins’ earlier assertions of a romantic proposal from Gein, she later clarified that they were merely friends and retracted her previous remarks. The truth regarding their relationship remains elusive, as Gein never publicly addressed his alleged involvement with Watkins.
The conflicting narratives surrounding Adeline Watkins and Ed Gein’s relationship add a layer of intrigue to the series, leaving viewers pondering the authenticity of their connection. The complexities of their interactions and the differing testimonies contribute to the enigmatic legacy of Ed Gein.