Ministers have decided to withdraw an amendment to the Hillsborough Law concerning the intelligence services following criticism from bereaved families and MPs. Keir Starmer was under pressure as the bill, named after the 1989 tragedy and aimed at preventing future state cover-ups, faced renewed discussion in the Commons on Monday. The proposed legislation includes a “duty of candour” requirement for public officials to act honestly or potentially face criminal penalties.
An amendment by the government intended to include MI5 and MI6 spies under the law, with approval from their service heads, was met with opposition from campaigners and bereaved families. Concerns were raised that this provision could allow security service leaders to determine information disclosure. Discussions between stakeholders and the government were ongoing over the weekend.
It has been revealed that the amendment will not be presented on Monday, as the government plans to collaborate with families to introduce changes in the House of Lords.
Keir Starmer, who has engaged with bereaved families and received support from campaigners, assured that the integrity of the Bill would be maintained. A government spokesperson emphasized the legislation’s aim to enhance transparency in governance and ensure accountability when mistakes occur, without compromising national security.
MP Ian Byrne, present at the Hillsborough tragedy, expressed satisfaction with the amendment’s withdrawal and urged the government to consider alternative adjustments aligned with the law’s spirit. Mayors of Liverpool and Manchester also urged withdrawal of an amendment they deemed too broad regarding spy exemptions. Labour MP Justin Madders supported the call for withdrawal, echoing the mayors’ sentiments.
Following the government’s decision to retract the amendment, MP Justin Madders welcomed the move and expressed optimism for further progress in addressing the concerns raised by families. Culture Secretary Ms. Nandy clarified that the security services would not be exempt from the “duty of candour,” emphasizing the need to avoid situations like the Manchester Arena inquiry where information was withheld from families and public inquiries.
Ms. Nandy affirmed ongoing discussions to resolve the matter, highlighting the importance of transparency in handling sensitive information.